McGrath posted 89 in Essendon's 43-point home belting by Fremantle — a premium-against-the-grain performance, exactly what he showed in R7 with 94 in a 77-point loss. The pattern is locked: 53 (blip), 109, 94, 70, 89 in recent rounds, and the 88.5 average at $391.3k with a 57 BE is genuinely elite MID/DEF value. Cash gen is marginal negative at -$2,981/week but that's rounding error at this price. Hold him with full conviction — he's the kind of premium who scores through team disasters, and they don't come along often at $391k.
PLAYERS / ANDREW MCGRATH
Updated 17 May 2026
Andrew Mcgrath
#42/177·Bye Rd 12
DEF
Price $391kBE 57Owned —Bye Rd 12Avg 88.5
ROOKIEBIBLEVerdict
— HOLD
Signals1/3 · Weak alignment
Form
DecliningTrajectory
-$3k/wkConsistency
ConsistentRecent formSeason avg 89
89
70▼
53▼
Comparable PicksWhy this comparison · Same primary position (DEF), ±$200k price band
Andrew Mcgrath
DEFJacob Weitering
DEF—
—
Form
R5
53
R6
109
R7
94
R8
53
R9
70
R10
89
R4
52
R6
100
R7
87
R8
76
R9
69
R10
66
Pricing
Price$391k
Price$391k
Breakeven57
Breakeven57
Decision
Should I trade Andrew Mcgrath?
Form, breakeven, and a comparable replacement weighed up.
Intel feed
Recent intel
Role Change· T3
Andy McGrath has transitioned from key defensive role to midfield, with community and media reporting this move is reigniting the Dons. With Ridley anchoring the backline when healthy, McGrath is freed to operate through the middle alongside Merrett, Parish, Caldwell, and Tsatas.
Community Questions
What people are asking about Andrew Mcgrath
Mentioned in
- Is Elijah Tsatas safe in the Essendon team and worth holding in SC?24E. TsatasMIDTop: Safe — hold with confidence (85%)