May bounced back with 81 in ESS's 18-point road loss to Richmond — his best score of the season and a genuine counter-cyclical return in a proper contest. After the damaging 28 in R10 that had the exit conversation starting, this flips the script: well above his 36 BE, well above his 47.5 average, and the kind of score that means the vest concern from earlier rounds is not the story. Cash gen was sliding negative but this pulls it back. Buy the reversal — he's earned another week.
PLAYERS / ARCHIE MAY
Updated 28 June 2026
Archie May
#125/167·⚠ out - Shoulder (Season)
FWD
Price $228kBE 34Owned —Avg 45.0
ROOKIEBIBLEVerdict
▲ BUY
Signals1/3 · Weak alignment
Form
StableTrajectory
-$2k/wkConsistency
VariableRecent formSeason avg 45
81▲
28▼
65▲
Comparable PicksWhy this comparison · Same primary position (FWD), ±$200k price band
Archie May
FWDArcher Day Wicks
FWD—
—
Form
R5
36
R6
73
R7
19
R9
65
R10
28
R11
81
R10
65
R11
24
R12
56
R13
35
R14
53
R16
54
Pricing
Price$228k
Price$227k
Breakeven34
Breakeven33
Cash/wk+$-2k
Cash/wk+$4k
Decision
Should I trade Archie May?
Form, breakeven, and a comparable replacement weighed up.
Intel feed
Recent intel
Breakout Signal· T3
Archie May drawing strong community praise for his contested marking, recording 8 tackles alongside strong marking work in R6. Multiple commenters highlighting his hands as elite and his physicality — commenters note there is 4-5kg more muscle to fill in on his frame. Community going from doubters to believers week-on-week.
Community Intel· T3
Archie May (Archer May) extended at Essendon until 2028. Community broadly positive about the retention of a key forward who has been impressing this season.
No community questions yet for Archie May. Be the first to ask.