Skip to main content
PLAYERS / CALEB WINDSOR
Updated 9 June 2026

Caleb Windsor

#140/184·Bye Rd 13·⚠ test - Toe (Test)
DEF
Price $287kBE 42Owned 15%Bye Rd 13Avg 55.8
ROOKIEBIBLEVerdict
◉ WATCH

Windsor scored 53 in Melbourne's 49-point belting by GWS — 5 above his 48 BE in a game Melbourne were dominated from the first bounce. After the R11 sell call (37, hobbling from toe), this is his second game back from injury and the second consecutive above-BE score (37 does not qualify, but 53 in a blowout does). Cash gen at $1,917/wk is technically positive. He is not right yet — 53 in a 49-point loss at Traeger Park is a survival score not a form reversal. Watch — if he backs it up with a genuine performance against a proper opponent, the hold call returns.

Signals0/3 · No alignment
Form
Declining
Trajectory
Flat
Consistency
Variable
Recent formSeason avg 56
44▼
53
37▼
Comparable PicksWhy this comparison · Same primary position (DEF), ±$200k price band

Caleb Windsor

DEF

James Trezise

DEF
—
—
Form
R7
102
R8
85
R9
80
R11
37
R12
53
R13
44
R7
71
R8
65
R9
82
R10
97
R11
60
R12
46
Pricing
Price$287k
Price$287k
Breakeven42
Breakeven42
Cash/wk+$0k
Cash/wk+$0k

Decision

Should I trade Caleb Windsor?

Form, breakeven, and a comparable replacement weighed up.

Intel feed

Recent intel

R5Trade Out Trending· T1

#4 most traded out this round with 4,809 trades (5.6% of coaches)

Source
Injury Watch· T3

Caleb Windsor is a test for R11 after passing a fitness test requirement. Uncertain availability for SC.

Melbourne FC injury report post (r/melbournefc)
Injury Watch· T3

Caleb Windsor ruled out for Melbourne vs Hawthorn R10 with a toe injury. Named in the official team changes post (Out: C.Windsor - toe).

u/corporate_canetoad (post, score 9)
Injury Watch· T3

Caleb Windsor listed as a test after sustaining a toe injury on Sunday. Official Melbourne injury report confirms he is being monitored and a final decision expected Thursday. Cross-reference with post-match thread confirms ankle/foot concern.

u/corporate_canetoad on r/melbournefc (post, 6 comments)
Injury Watch· T3

Caleb Windsor sustained an ankle/toe injury in Round 9 vs West Coast. Post-match community comments flagged the concern, and a separate Melbourne injury list post confirms it as a mid-foot area injury being monitored with a final decision expected by Thursday.

u/minecraft360 on r/melbournefc (post, 34 comments); comment score 3 mentions Windsor ankle
Breakout Signal· T3

Caleb Windsor had his best AFL game in R7 vs Richmond, kicking two goals and winning multiple fan votes as 2nd or 3rd best. One commenter called it "best game for a long time (maybe best ever for Windsor)." His form coming along quickly.

u/Deevious730 + multiple commenters on r/melbournefc (post match, score 10+)
Community Intel· T3

Community recommends trading Windsor this week if trades are available, mentioned alongside Watkins as a priority out.

u/Rogan4Life, u/PsychologySeparate85, u/oThomasJack on r/AFLSupercoach
Community Intel· T3

Caleb Windsor showed inconsistency again — community describing him as a one-week hero, one-week no-show. Growing sentiment that he needs a stint in the VFL to find his role. A few commenters noting Windsor is not an on-baller.

u/Simply_charmingMan (score 3), u/Acceptable-Young-898 (score 3), r/melbournefc

No community questions yet for Caleb Windsor. Be the first to ask.