Dear posted 32 in a 39-point hammering by Melbourne at the MCG — well below his 39 BE and the worst score since his R3 struggles. Three of his last four rounds have been at or below BE (38, 51, 32), confirming the R6 104 was a flash, not a breakout. Cash gen has turned negative at -$643/wk and the role has never locked in at Hawthorn. Sell — there is no case to hold a boom-bust forward bleeding cash at $267k.
Signals0/3 · No alignment
Form
Declining
Trajectory
Flat
Consistency
Volatile
Calsher Dear
·Bye Rd 12·⚠ out - Hip/Groin (1-2 weeks)
FWD
SC Avg32.0
Form
Break-even39↓ falling
Price$267k3wk ↑ $270k
Owned—
Value0.1poor
BELOW BE — 7 pts under BE. Price falling.$-1k/wk
R0
R1
R2
R3
—
R4
R5
R6
104
R7
38
How they compare
Calsher Dear
FWD
Hussien El Achkar
FWD
—
—
Form
R6
104
R7
38
R8
51
R10
32
R1
40
R2
24
Pricing
Price$267k
Price$114k
Breakeven39
Breakeven17
Cash/wk+$-1k
Cash/wk+$0k
But this is generic. Your team changes everything.
Sam Mitchell
MID
AVG94
3GM102
BKE88
PRICE$485k
Trade Mitchell → upgrade Xerri to Grundy. Frees $38k and fixes your ruck.
Your personalised recommendation
Upload your team and get a specific answer — who to trade Calsher Dear for, what it does to your bye structure, and what it opens up for your season.