Houston posted 75 in R10, barely clearing his 72 BE, while multiple commentators flagged soft body contests costing Collingwood goals and describing his effort as poor. At $489k that is not premium defender performance — it is a below-par contested showing in a game his team clearly needed more from him. Sell on the marginal BE-clearing score before the narrative hardens and the price slides.
Dan Houston
Dan Houston
DEFJosh Battle
DEFDecision
Should I trade Dan Houston?
Form, breakeven, and a comparable replacement weighed up.
Recent intel
Dan Houston heavily criticised for multiple soft efforts and weak body contests in R10 vs Sydney. Community notes he cost Collingwood 3 goals in a quarter and is 'soft as butter'. Multiple high-score comments confirm negative assessment; described as accepting mediocrity.
Dan Houston (COLL) SC role discussed: community consensus is hold him as a luxury final-upgrade target averaging ~90. Trade rookies off the field before moving Houston. His role is seen as good and consistent, not a sell candidate yet.
Dan Houston hold-vs-trade debate continues. One commenter advises holding — break-even is not enormous, wet conditions last week did not suit him, and with ongoing injuries there are bigger priorities to address.
Dan Houston being considered for trade out but coach leaning toward holding to see performance at MCG in likely dry conditions. Houston hold-vs-trade is an active community debate this round.
Dan Houston under trade pressure. Coach weighing whether to trade him out this round but community split — some advise hold as his SC-favourable role is intact and he is not injured.
#10 most popular trade: Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera → Dan Houston (791 trades, 1%)
#7 most popular trade: Archie Roberts → Dan Houston (985 trades, 1.2%)
What people are asking about Dan Houston
- Is Oscar Steene worth picking up given his R6 ruck-forward breakout?31O. SteeneFWDTop: Pick him up immediately (70%)
- Which players are the best upgrade and downgrade targets heading into Round 7?24UnknownTop: Anderson and Tsatas are the mid downgrade targets (45%)
Related Articles
Best Defender Under $500k for Round 10: Bailey Dale vs Dayne Zorko vs the Field
Community split 40/35/15/10 on Zorko/Dale/Houston/Other. R9 confirmed the right order is Dale → Zorko → Houston, with McKay off the table.
Read article →Who Comes In for Rozee? Dan Houston, Tom Stewart, or Hold
Connor Rozee is out with a soft tissue injury and coaches need a replacement. Here's the case for every option — Houston, Stewart, Zorko, and holding — with the numbers to back it up.
Read article →