Richards blasted 130 in a 4-point arm-wrestle win over Collingwood at Docklands — back-to-back 130+ scores (140 in R11, 130 in R12) is elite form in two genuinely contested games. The concern is the season average sits at only 62 because he was erratic earlier; at $526.8k with a 62 avg the value score is ugly at 0.118. Hold if you have him through this hot streak, but don't buy now at $527k — when the regression comes it will be steep. Cash gen still negative at -$2,796/wk, price drifting down.
Ed Richards
Ed Richards
MIDErrol Gulden
MIDDecision
Should I trade Ed Richards?
Form, breakeven, and a comparable replacement weighed up.
Recent intel
Ed Richards received the most Player of the Year votes from WB fans for R11 vs Melbourne, winning 3-votes in the majority of fan ballots. Dominant performance affirmed as his best showing of the season.
Ed Richards was dominant in WB win vs Melbourne, named BOG in multiple fan votes receiving top 3-votes from multiple commenters. Described as 'back to his absolute best'. Multiple positive mentions across post-match and POTY thread.
Ed Richards described as clearly off and heartbreaking to watch in WB R10 loss; community believes he is playing through injury.
Ed Richards described as "clearly playing injured" and looking off in WB R10 loss; community speculation he is carrying a physical complaint.
Community discussion around trading Ed Richards out as a premo underperformer. Dominant comment sentiment is hold — multiple commenters argue his 104 average and a 140 high score justify patience over trading. A minority are frustrated and want him moved on.
Ed Richards is named as one of the Western Bulldogs players "under clouds" heading into R7, alongside Bontempelli. No specifics on injury type provided; community treating it as a fitness concern for this week.
Ed Richards gave a notably passionate post-match interview after the R6 Geelong loss, visibly angry at the team performance ('hung them out to dry'). High-intensity response suggests strong team-first character; may play through injury in coming weeks if cleared.
Ed Richards was spotted at training with his ankle/knee area looking healthy, approximately 9 days after the R5 tendon injury report. Possible early return signal, though no official clearance noted.
What people are asking about Ed Richards
- Should I trade out Richards to bring in Lachie Neale as a midfield premium upgrade?11L. NealeMIDTop: Hold Richards, do not trade premo-for-premo (75%)