Ralphsmith managed just 47 in Richmond's 54-point loss to Melbourne at the MCG — 4 above his 43 BE but well below any premium expectation. His season average sits at 34 against a $294.1k price with -$3,806/week cash gen; the price is still too high for what he delivers. After a brief 56 in R6 raised faint hope, this performance confirms the avoid remains warranted — he's a cash drain in a losing side.