Skip to main content
PLAYERS / ISAAC CUMMING
Updated 28 June 2026

Isaac Cumming

#71/138·⚠ test - Hamstring (Test)
MID
Price $333kBE 49Owned —Avg 73.0
ROOKIEBIBLEVerdict
▼ SELL

Cumming put up 77 in Adelaide's 68-point demolition of North Melbourne — the margin is enormous so this is a garbage-time number, and minor hamstring soreness has been flagged post-game. 27 above his 50 BE but cash gen is still draining at -$1,228/wk. The injury concern from R9 (surgery whisper) hasn't been definitively cleared and now there's a new hamstring flag. Sell this week — hamstring plus surgery history plus a cash gen drain is too much uncertainty to carry.

Signals0/3 · No alignment
Form
Declining
Trajectory
-$1k/wk
Consistency
Variable
Recent formSeason avg 73
52▼
77▲
66▼
Comparable PicksWhy this comparison · Same primary position (MID), ±$200k price band

Isaac Cumming

MID

Marcus Windhager

MID
—
—
Form
R6
33
R7
110
R8
55
R9
66
R10
77
R16
52
R10
64
R11
69
R12
49
R13
36
R14
88
R15
99
Pricing
Price$333k
Price$332k
Breakeven49
Breakeven49

Decision

Should I trade Isaac Cumming?

Form, breakeven, and a comparable replacement weighed up.

Intel feed

Recent intel

Community Intel· T3

Isaac Cumming (ADEL) scored 72 in the previous round, framed as the conservative hold compared to the tagging risk of Murdock. Community comment also suggests trading Cumming out for a premium.

u/Old-Savings-566 on r/AFLSupercoach (post) | u/shadysnore (comment, score 2)
Community Intel· T3

Isaac Cumming flagged by SC community as a trade-out target heading into R10; however one commenter notes he has cash to make and just needs an 80+ score to kick-start cash gen.

u/No_Philosopher_2848 + u/runburrarun on r/AFLSupercoach
Breakout Signal· T3

Isaac Cumming described as "the best he has been in his 3 quarters off half-back" against the Swans R10, generating momentum for a spot against the Hawks. Minor hamstring soreness flagged as caveat.

u/No_Divide_4336 + u/Right-Jury1787 on r/adelaidefc
Injury Watch· T3

Community reports Isaac Cumming injured and requiring surgery, expected to miss until mid-season bye. SC owners debating whether to trade in or avoid.

u/0367778b post on r/AFLSupercoach
Breakout Signal· T3

Community broadly endorsing Isaac Cumming as the top cash cow option this week, ranked first among cheap options by multiple commenters.

u/JackassJamie (post) + u/bazoski1er (comment, score 2)
Community Intel· T3

Isaac Cumming described in the post title as a potential must-have by a community member reviewing their squad. Positive sentiment around his SC value and inclusion in teams.

u/HamsterVisual5983 on r/AFLSupercoach (post)
Community Intel· T3

Isaac Cumming receives positive sentiment in a rate-my-team thread, with a commenter expressing strong approval of him as a selection.

u/crabsy92 (comment, score 3) on r/AFLSupercoach
Community Intel· T3

Cumming mentioned as a top rookie target for R7, though commenters flag Pittonet is expected back this week or next which could reduce his role.

u/AccurateSituation317 (comment, score 7) | u/MarketOk3786 (comment, score 6)
Community Questions

What people are asking about Isaac Cumming

Mentioned in
  • Should I trade out Milan Murdock given his move to a tagging role, or hold him through his bye?
    M. MurdockMIDTop: Hold through bye rounds (58%)
    49
  • Should non-owners trade in Bontempelli this week despite knee and heel concerns?
    M. BontempelliMIDTop: Bring in Bont now (55%)
    39
  • Should SuperCoach owners move on from Dan Curtin given his demotion to the SANFL, or hold for his imminent return?
    D. CurtinMIDTop: Hold — imminent AFL return, SANFL stint was managed (60%)
    31
  • Which rookies are worth trading in for Round 8, and who is the top priority?
    UnknownTop: Retschko is the must-have trade-in (55%)
    11
  • When is the best time to trade in Tristan Xerri, or should I prioritise him over defence upgrades this week?
    T. XerriRUCTop: Bring in Xerri before round 14 (65%)
    11