Skip to main content
PLAYERS / ISAAC CUMMING
Updated 17 May 2026

Isaac Cumming

#77/138·Bye Rd 12·⚠ test - Hamstring (Test)
MID
Price $340kBE 50Owned —Bye Rd 12Avg 73.0
ROOKIEBIBLEVerdict
▼ SELL

Cumming put up 77 in Adelaide's 68-point demolition of North Melbourne — the margin is enormous so this is a garbage-time number, and minor hamstring soreness has been flagged post-game. 27 above his 50 BE but cash gen is still draining at -$1,228/wk. The injury concern from R9 (surgery whisper) hasn't been definitively cleared and now there's a new hamstring flag. Sell this week — hamstring plus surgery history plus a cash gen drain is too much uncertainty to carry.

Signals1/3 · Weak alignment
Form
Stable
Trajectory
-$1k/wk
Consistency
Variable
Recent formSeason avg 73
77▲
66▼
55▼
Comparable PicksWhy this comparison · Same primary position (MID), ±$200k price band

Isaac Cumming

MID

Xavier Duursma

MID
—
—
Form
R5
76
R6
33
R7
110
R8
55
R9
66
R10
77
R5
107
R6
75
R7
59
R8
54
R9
72
R10
70
Pricing
Price$340k
Price$340k
Breakeven50
Breakeven50

Decision

Should I trade Isaac Cumming?

Form, breakeven, and a comparable replacement weighed up.

Intel feed

Recent intel

Community Intel· T3

Isaac Cumming flagged by SC community as a trade-out target heading into R10; however one commenter notes he has cash to make and just needs an 80+ score to kick-start cash gen.

u/No_Philosopher_2848 + u/runburrarun on r/AFLSupercoach
Breakout Signal· T3

Isaac Cumming described as "the best he has been in his 3 quarters off half-back" against the Swans R10, generating momentum for a spot against the Hawks. Minor hamstring soreness flagged as caveat.

u/No_Divide_4336 + u/Right-Jury1787 on r/adelaidefc
Injury Watch· T3

Community reports Isaac Cumming injured and requiring surgery, expected to miss until mid-season bye. SC owners debating whether to trade in or avoid.

u/0367778b post on r/AFLSupercoach
Breakout Signal· T3

Community broadly endorsing Isaac Cumming as the top cash cow option this week, ranked first among cheap options by multiple commenters.

u/JackassJamie (post) + u/bazoski1er (comment, score 2)
Community Intel· T3

Isaac Cumming described in the post title as a potential must-have by a community member reviewing their squad. Positive sentiment around his SC value and inclusion in teams.

u/HamsterVisual5983 on r/AFLSupercoach (post)
Community Intel· T3

Isaac Cumming receives positive sentiment in a rate-my-team thread, with a commenter expressing strong approval of him as a selection.

u/crabsy92 (comment, score 3) on r/AFLSupercoach
Community Intel· T3

Cumming mentioned as a top rookie target for R7, though commenters flag Pittonet is expected back this week or next which could reduce his role.

u/AccurateSituation317 (comment, score 7) | u/MarketOk3786 (comment, score 6)
Community Intel· T4

Isaac Cumming criticised by multiple commenters as not good enough for Adelaide best 23; question marks over his selection.

u/CheckZestyclose480 + u/Specialist_Form_149 on r/adelaidefc (scores 9+8)
Community Questions

What people are asking about Isaac Cumming

Mentioned in
  • Should non-owners trade in Bontempelli this week despite knee and heel concerns?
    M. BontempelliMIDTop: Bring in Bont now (55%)
    39
  • Should SuperCoach owners move on from Dan Curtin given his demotion to the SANFL, or hold for his imminent return?
    D. CurtinMIDTop: Hold — imminent AFL return, SANFL stint was managed (60%)
    31
  • Which rookies are worth trading in for Round 8, and who is the top priority?
    UnknownTop: Retschko is the must-have trade-in (55%)
    11
  • When is the best time to trade in Tristan Xerri, or should I prioritise him over defence upgrades this week?
    T. XerriRUCTop: Bring in Xerri before round 14 (65%)
    11