What is Jack Silvagni's SuperCoach breakeven?

Jack Silvagni's breakeven is 46. The current average of 76 sits 30 points above breakeven, so the price is rising.

Should I trade Jack Silvagni in SuperCoach 2026?

The answer depends on your team — your cash, your byes, and what the upgrade target looks like. The dedicated Should I Trade Jack Silvagni breakdown weighs form, breakeven, and a comparable replacement side-by-side.

Will Jack Silvagni and Tom De Koning get booed by Carlton fans when they return to face their former club?

Boo JSOS, not TDK. The strongest view was to boo Silvagni but not De Koning. TDK was offered life-changing money (reportedly $12m+) that almost anyone would accept, while JSOS was seen as leaving for more complex reasons tied to the Silvagni family connection with St Kilda list management and the awkwardness of being drafted on his father’s name.

Jack Silvagni SuperCoach 2026 Profile & Stats | RookieBible

PLAYERS / JACK SILVAGNI

Updated 17 May 2026

Jack Silvagni

#77/177⚡ Cap option·Bye Rd 12

DEF

Price $314kBE 46Owned —Bye Rd 12Avg 76.0

ROOKIEBIBLEVerdict

▼ SELL

Silvagni managed 66 in STK's 29-point away loss in Darwin — clearing his 47 BE but bleeding cash at -$3,941 per round. After R8's 25-point vest game, 66 looks like a recovery but the underlying story hasn't changed. He's been called a sell for the last two rounds and R9 doesn't reverse that — the price erosion means every week you hold costs you. Trade him out now.

Signals1/3 · Weak alignment

Form

Stable

Trajectory

-$4k/wk

Consistency

Variable

Recent formSeason avg 76

86▲

66▼

25▼

Comparable PicksWhy this comparison · Same primary position (DEF), ±$200k price band

Jack Silvagni

DEF

Joshua Weddle

DEF

—

Form

121

R10

Pricing

Price$314k

Price$316k

Breakeven46

Decision

Should I trade Jack Silvagni?

Form, breakeven, and a comparable replacement weighed up.

Intel feed

Recent intel

Community Intel· T3

Jack Silvagni (JSOS) expected to receive heavy booing from Carlton fans upon returning. Commenters broadly agree he will cop it more than TDK, with the anger directed partly at his father Stephen Silvagni (list manager at STK) for the circumstances of his departure.

u/Sabretoothedrom on r/CarltonBlues (post), comments score 40/28/10

Community Intel· T3

Jack Silvagni rated as the 11th highest key defender in the comp in 2026. Referenced positively in Saints R6 post-match discussion as an emerging defensive asset.

u/shadysnore on r/StKilda (comment, score 9)

Breakout Signal· T3

Jack Silvagni described as showing great grit in the STK vs Port Adelaide win at Gather Round. Community notes it is his best form in a long time and rates him as one of the standouts from the tight victory.

u/Fit_Landscape6820 + u/AmenCaveman on r/StKilda (post-match comments)

Community Questions

Jack Silvagni

Recent intel

What people are asking about Jack Silvagni

Will Jack Silvagni and Tom De Koning get booed by Carlton fans when they return to face their former club?