What is James Sicily's SuperCoach breakeven?

James Sicily's breakeven is 70. The current average of 102 sits 32 points above breakeven, so the price is rising.

Should I trade James Sicily in SuperCoach 2026?

The answer depends on your team — your cash, your byes, and what the upgrade target looks like. The dedicated Should I Trade James Sicily breakdown weighs form, breakeven, and a comparable replacement side-by-side.

What changes should Hawthorn make for the R7 Suns game with Sicily and Moore suspended?

Scrimshaw for Sicily, Dalton and Gunston in for Moore and McCabe. Overwhelming consensus on a three-change selection: Scrimshaw is the obvious like-for-like replacement for Sicily in defence, Dalton slots into the high HF role vacated by Moore, and Gunston returns to replace the underperforming McCabe. Multiple high-scored comments aligned on exactly this combination.

James Sicily SuperCoach 2026 Profile & Stats | RookieBible

PLAYERS / JAMES SICILY

Updated 17 May 2026

James Sicily

#18/177⚡ Cap option·Bye Rd 12·⚠ out - Suspended (Round 8)

DEF

Price $476kBE 70Owned —Bye Rd 12Avg 102.0

ROOKIEBIBLEVerdict

— HOLD

Sicily posted 114 in a 39-point away loss to Melbourne at the MCG — the team got rolled but he kept delivering, sitting 44 clear of his 70 BE and pushing his average above 100. Cash gen is nearly flat at -$300/week, but at $475.7k averaging 102 he is one of the most reliable premium DEFs in the competition. Three of his last four scores have been 100+. Hold with conviction — do not overthink this one.

Signals2/3 · Partial alignment

Form

Improving

Trajectory

Flat

Consistency

Consistent

Recent formSeason avg 102

114▲

110▲

87▼

Comparable PicksWhy this comparison · Same primary position (DEF), ±$200k price band

James Sicily

DEF

Luke Ryan

DEF

—

Form

106

110

R10

114

126

116

119

R10

Pricing

Price$476k

Price$482k

Breakeven70

Breakeven71

Decision

Should I trade James Sicily?

Form, breakeven, and a comparable replacement weighed up.

Intel feed

Recent intel

Injury Watch· T3

Community asking about James Sicily ankle status ahead of a Fremantle clash. No official update yet but community monitoring his availability; noted he would be a significant loss.

u/Cautious-Home-9229 on r/hawktalk (post)

Community Intel· T3

James Sicily rated 9.0/10 in HAW vs PIE review: 22 disposals at 91%, 9 marks, 12 intercepts. Reviewer praised his suspension appearing to motivate him. Community confident in his form but monitoring ankle heading into Freo game.

u/Kind_Security_9931 on r/hawktalk (post, score 30)

Role Change· T3

James Sicily received a 1-game suspension from MRO Michael Christian for striking Logan Evans during the R6 Hawthorn vs Port Adelaide match. He will miss R7 vs Gold Coast. Multiple community posts and comments confirm the ban.

u/Darththorn on r/hawktalk (post) + 10+ confirming comments

Community Intel· T3

Sicily mentioned alongside Stewart as a veteran option worth considering when upgrade targets are slim.

u/This_Ease_5678 on r/AFLSupercoach

Community Questions

What people are asking about James Sicily

Mentioned in

What is Hawthorn's best 23 when fully healthy?
UnknownTop: Chol and Day in; Dear and Maginness out (60%)
12