Gibcus didn't take the field in R3 and is listed as omitted, which is a concern given preseason intel had him slated to play. At $139.6k with a 20 BE he has huge cash generation potential, but you can't pick a player who isn't playing. Avoid until he earns a confirmed spot in Richmond's 22.
Josh Gibcus
DEFOskar Taylor
DEFDecision
Should I trade Josh Gibcus?
Form, breakeven, and a comparable replacement weighed up.
Josh Gibcus has been added to Richmond's injury list, with the VFL analyst noting he will likely be moved to the inactive player list and open up a mid-season draft spot. This was referenced across two separate posts in r/RichmondFC as part of a broader ongoing injury crisis at the club.
Josh Gibcus ACL sprain described as approaching cooked status. High-engagement post (46 comments) with multiple fans raising serious concerns about career viability and Richmond S&C program under Serpell.
Josh Gibcus suffered an ACL sprain (not rupture). Extended absence expected. Community concerned about his career trajectory after repeated setbacks; comments suggest even when fit he has looked well off the pace.
Josh Gibcus briefly came off in the VFL game prompting concern but returned and appeared fine. No injury confirmed; community relieved.
Noah Gibcus has not played VFL or AFL for 3 weeks and is not listed on the official injury report, raising community concern about an undisclosed issue or delisting risk.
Split community opinion — one user recommends trading Gibcus out while another advises holding. Suggests uncertainty around his value or role.
Labelled a 'failed rookie', being considered for trade out when cash permits.
No community questions yet for Josh Gibcus. Be the first to ask.