Skip to main content
PLAYERS / LOUIS EMMETT
Updated 17 May 2026

Louis Emmett

#23/25
RUC
Price $142kBE 21Owned —Avg 26.0
ROOKIEBIBLEVerdict
▼ SELL

Emmett beat his 21 BE with 26 against Carlton but this is false comfort — he's been publicly labelled not AFL-ready by fans and analysts across two consecutive games, and was brought in to replace Lachie Smith only to deliver another non-event. The consensus is emphatic: he'll be sent back to the VFL. Sell the residual value this week before the axe falls again.

Signals1/3 · Weak alignment
Form
Declining
Trajectory
+$1k/wk
Consistency
Volatile
Recent formSeason avg 26
26
1▼
44▲
Comparable PicksWhy this comparison · Same primary position (RUC), ±$200k price band

Louis Emmett

RUC

Callum Coleman Jones

RUC
—
—
Form
R5
37
R6
56
R7
44
R8
1
R10
26
R4
29
R5
45
R6
66
Pricing
Price$142k
Price$159k
Breakeven21
Breakeven23
Cash/wk+$1k
Cash/wk+$2k

Decision

Should I trade Louis Emmett?

Form, breakeven, and a comparable replacement weighed up.

Intel feed

Recent intel

Vest Risk· T3

Louis Emmett criticised across multiple high-scoring comments in WB post-match thread as not at AFL standard; looked nervous, contributed nothing, called to be sent to VFL. Strong consensus across thread.

u/GateNervous9380 (score 7) + u/Thefoz95 (score 3) + others on r/westernbulldogs
Vest Risk· T3

Louis Emmett widely criticised as not at AFL standard after WB R10 loss to Carlton; multiple commenters called for him to return to VFL to develop more. Tagged as not ready for senior football.

u/Dub_Heem + u/coolcumber211 + multiple commenters on r/westernbulldogs (score 30+)
Community Intel· T3

Louis Emmett named in WB side for R10, replacing Lachie Smith. Community strongly negative — one effective disposal and only 2 hitouts from 30 ruck contests last game. Multiple comments say he has no business being in the side.

u/Temitop_dream (post), u/nagooey88 (score 33), u/Eternalism (score 19), u/Powerful_Chemical628 (score 14)
Role Change· T3

Louis Emmett was used in the ruck against Fremantle in R8 and was widely criticised as not AFL-ready, recording only 2 hitouts from 30 ruck contests and allowing opposition midfield dominance. Multiple commenters argued Emmett should be replaced by Jordan Croft or Lachlan Smith, citing his physical unreadiness for AFL-level ruck contests.

multiple commenters (scores 10,8,8,5,4,3) on r/westernbulldogs post-match thread
Vest Risk· T3

Louis Emmett is omitted (not injured) for Round 7 vs Sydney Swans, with debutant Lachlan Smith taking the ruck duties. The omission rather than injury suggests a form-based selection call.

u/Temitop_dream on r/westernbulldogs (post)
Breakout Signal· T3

Louis Emmett made his AFL debut for the Western Bulldogs in R5 against Hawthorn as a 19-year-old ruckman filling in for the injured Tim English. Community notes he has a strong leap and good tank. While it was a tough introduction, he showed positive signs and the new ruck rules suit his athleticism.

u/No-Blacksmith-3259, multiple (r/westernbulldogs, 13 comments)

No community questions yet for Louis Emmett. Be the first to ask.