Thomas Stewart scored 68 — 10 below his 78 BE in a tight game. Cash gen positive at $961/wk. Watch — one near-miss doesn't trigger a trade but consecutive misses will.
Thomas Stewart
DEFJeremy Howe
DEFDecision
Should I trade Thomas Stewart?
Form, breakeven, and a comparable replacement weighed up.
Thomas Stewart's fitness/availability questioned in SC trade discussions. Community member notes they do not trust Stewart to stay fit, flagging him as an injury-risk trade target.
Thomas Stewart flagged as managed and rollercoaster SC ownership; his role has been taken by Max Holmes at times this season, adding selection and scoring risk in the backline.
Post-game concern that Tom Stewart may have hurt his hamstring in the final 20 seconds vs Brisbane R10. Stewart himself denied the injury in post-match interview, reducing concern significantly.
Tom Stewart was dominant vs Brisbane (R10), described as his best performance in recent memory. Set up the game early with multiple intercept marks. Community concern after game re possible hamstring, but Stewart post-game denied injury.
Thomas Stewart under trade pressure at R09 with a BE of 124 and projected further price drop of ~20k. Community split between holding and cutting losses, with replacement options being Roberts or Callaghan.
Tom Stewart hold-or-sell question with Holmes moving back to defence is dividing the community. Comments lean toward holding: two commenters note Stewart's recent low scores are attributable to Geelong winning big against weak opponents (combined 84 i50 over two weeks), not role loss, and he remains prone to 150-point ceiling games.
Thomas Stewart's SuperCoach scoring has been hurt by Holmes moving to defence, reducing intercept opportunities. Community consensus is that if the Holmes role holds, Stewart's output could be structurally reduced for the remainder of the season.
Community discussing whether Thomas Stewart has lost scoring potential with Max Holmes stationed down back. OP believes Holmes down back is long-term but commenters strongly disagree — likely a one-off experiment while Holmes rests a finger injury.