GWS community discussing whether Toby Greene leaving would affect his Giants legacy. Majority say yes, it would taint his legacy — especially if he leaves late to "coat-tail" a premiership elsewhere. Some defend his right to chase a flag if the club can't contend. Community somewhat divided.

GWS fan assessment that Toby Greene looks done, named alongside Hogan, Cogs, and Briggs as players past their peak. Corroborates R8 post-game thread sentiment from same round.

Multiple commenters across the GWS post-game thread describe Toby Greene as looking done/washed, with no effort or fight. Named alongside Hogan as players whose time at GWS may be over. Strong consensus sentiment.