McMullin posted 54 in GWS's commanding 49-point away win over Melbourne at Traeger Park — clearing his 30 BE by 24 points and posting his best score since returning from injury. The trajectory is undeniably positive (15 → 38 → 54 across the last three games) and the 54 came in genuine midfield function during a dominant team performance. But at $200.9k with cash gen still negative at -$1,339/wk and a value score of just 0.105, the price has not yet begun to reflect even these modest gains. He has been a season-long avoid (injury, then 15, then injury, then injury) and one 54 does not rewrite the story. Watch next round — if he backs it up, the buy-in window opens.
Signals1/3 · Weak alignment
Form
Improving
Trajectory
Flat
Consistency
Volatile
Toby Mcmullin
·⚠ out - Hamstring (1 week)
MID
SC Avg23.0
Form
Break-even31↓ falling
Price$209k3wk ↑ $242k
Owned—
Value0.1poor
BELOW BE — 8 pts under BE. Price falling.$-1k/wk
R0
R1
R2
R3
R4
—
R5
R6
38
R7
How they compare
Toby Mcmullin
MID
Benny Barrett
MID
—
—
Form
R6
38
R9
15
R10
21
R11
63
R12
54
R14
23
—
Pricing
Price$209k
Price$120k
Breakeven31
Breakeven18
Cash/wk+$-1k
Cash/wk+$0k
But this is generic. Your team changes everything.
Sam Mitchell
MID
AVG94
3GM102
BKE88
PRICE$485k
Trade Mitchell → upgrade Xerri to Grundy. Frees $38k and fixes your ruck.
Your personalised recommendation
Read the latest SuperCoach thought pieces and player intel — grounded in prices, form, and community signal — before you pull the trigger on Toby Mcmullin.