What is Tom Mcdonald's SuperCoach breakeven?

Tom Mcdonald's breakeven is 56. The current average of 50 sits 6 points below breakeven, so the price is falling.

Should I trade Tom Mcdonald in SuperCoach 2026?

The answer depends on your team — your cash, your byes, and what the upgrade target looks like. The dedicated Should I Trade Tom Mcdonald breakdown weighs form, breakeven, and a comparable replacement side-by-side.

Tom Mcdonald SuperCoach 2026 Profile & Stats | RookieBible

PLAYERS / TOM MCDONALD

Updated 17 May 2026

Tom Mcdonald

#146/177·Bye Rd 12

DEF

Price $381kBE 56Owned —Bye Rd 12Avg 49.5

ROOKIEBIBLEVerdict

— HOLD

Tom McDonald returned a modest 60 in R5, barely clearing his 56 BE and averaging just 62.3 on the season at $380.7k. After the tantalising 88 in R3, this is a flat reset — he's scoring above breakeven but generating no meaningful cash. Hold if you own him, but at sub-70 average he's not worth chasing at this price.

Signals1/3 · Weak alignment

Form

Stable

Trajectory

-$1k/wk

Consistency

Variable

Recent formSeason avg 50

60▲

39▼

88▲

Comparable PicksWhy this comparison · Same primary position (DEF), ±$200k price band

Tom Mcdonald

DEF

Liam Duggan

DEF

—

Form

R10

104

Pricing

Price$381k

Price$379k

Breakeven56

Decision

Should I trade Tom Mcdonald?

Form, breakeven, and a comparable replacement weighed up.

Intel feed

Recent intel

Role Change· T3

Tom McDonald is widely considered done as a forward — multiple commenters state his forward career is finished, with one noting McDonald himself has acknowledged this. Community sees him as replaceable.

u/Royal_Photograph_887 (score 4), r/melbournefc

Community Questions

What people are asking about Tom Mcdonald

Mentioned in

Will Melbourne beat Richmond in Round 7 and by how much?
UnknownTop: Melbourne comfortable win (30+ margin) (65%)
33