Curnow returned from his abdominal scare and posted 34 in a tight 6-point Sydney win over Collingwood — not garbage time, a genuine arm-wrestle, and he delivered nothing. Below his 50 BE again and cash gen is still bleeding at -$1,568/wk. The one-game flash of 128 in R7 is well and truly a distant memory. His season average of 44.5 tells you everything. The R8 sell call stands — trade him out immediately and put the cash somewhere reliable.
Charlie Curnow
Charlie Curnow
FWDHarry Sharp
FWDDecision
Should I trade Charlie Curnow?
Form, breakeven, and a comparable replacement weighed up.
Recent intel
Charlie Curnow reported lower abdominal soreness after R8 and is listed as a test to return in Round 10. His absence in R9 was felt significantly in the forward line; multiple comments note the team struggled to enable crumbers without him.
Charlie Curnow's absence in R9 vs North Melbourne left a significant hole in the Sydney forward line. His unique ability to bring the ball to ground for crumbers was missed; Papley and Rosas were unable to function as effectively without him.
Charlie Curnow confirmed out via official team selection for R9 vs North Melbourne. McLean named as direct replacement in the tall forward role. Precautionary management with big games vs Collingwood and Geelong ahead.
Charlie Curnow is unavailable for Round 9 vs North Melbourne. Community treats this as precautionary management — he is noted as able to push through if needed but the team is being careful given depth available. Expected back the following week.
Charlie Curnow described as the structural anchor of Sydney's aerial forward setup. Commands opposition's best key defender weekly, freeing teammates. Contested marks and marks inside 50 metrics have improved dramatically since his arrival.
Charlie Curnow praised in Mongrel Punt review - multiple community comments agree he has arrived, media under-rated him. Multiple goals, contested marks, dominant forward presence.
Charlie Curnow kicked 7 goals with 6 contested marks - described as having arrived and silencing media critics. Community unanimous on his dominance in this game.
Charlie Curnow strongly backed by Sydney coach Dean Cox despite slow start on accuracy. Cox defended him publicly, highlighting 21 aerial contest wins, 1 loss and immediate positive impact on forward structure. Community consensus aligned with Cox: drop calls are uninformed.