Skip to main content
PLAYERS / JACK SCRIMSHAW
Updated 17 May 2026

Jack Scrimshaw

#166/177·Bye Rd 12·⚠ out - Knee (TBC)
DEF
Price $316kBE 46Owned —Bye Rd 12Avg 36.0
ROOKIEBIBLEVerdict
◉ WATCH

Scrimshaw crashed to 33 in the MCG draw with Collingwood — 17 below his 50 BE and a brutal reversal from his 94 breakout in R7. The R7 buy was predicated on his return for the suspended Sicily; question now is whether Sicily is back and Scrimshaw's role has been cut, or Collingwood simply shut him down in a tough arm-wrestle. At $315.8k averaging 45.5, the price isn't punishing but the scoring floor is unreliable. Watch until Sicily's status is confirmed and his role is clear.

Signals1/3 · Weak alignment
Form
Stable
Trajectory
Flat
Consistency
Volatile
Recent formSeason avg 36
33▼
94▲
36
Comparable PicksWhy this comparison · Same primary position (DEF), ±$200k price band

Jack Scrimshaw

DEF

Nathan Broad

DEF
—
—
Form
R0
78
R1
55
R2
75
R4
36
R7
94
R8
33
R5
86
R6
71
R7
40
R8
73
R9
57
R10
64
Pricing
Price$316k
Price$316k
Breakeven46
Breakeven46

Decision

Should I trade Jack Scrimshaw?

Form, breakeven, and a comparable replacement weighed up.

Intel feed

Recent intel

Injury Watch· T3

Jack Scrimshaw injured his knee at training Tuesday and ruled out vs Melbourne R10. Expected to miss only one game. This was confirmed in the post title as a direct injury report.

u/Darththorn (post, score 24)
Breakout Signal· T3

Jack Scrimshaw had a fantastic game in R7 vs Gold Coast Suns scoring 24 points. Multiple commenters highlighted Scrimshaw as needing to remain in the side, providing more flexibility as he can play tall or small with x-factor.

u/BoothaFett on r/hawktalk (post match, score 7)
Role Change· T3

Jack Scrimshaw widely expected to return to the HAW lineup in R7 to replace the suspended James Sicily. Multiple comments across three posts identify this as the obvious like-for-like replacement. Community views Scrimshaw as significantly above Perez and a certain starter when available.

u/Kluupix (comment, score 30) + u/oregon33 (comment, score 8) + u/BigTonkaTroy (comment, score 5) on r/hawktalk
Vest Risk· T3

Jack Scrimshaw not named in Hawks R6 squad despite being a quality player. Community believes it is soreness-related management after the Geelong game rather than a form drop. Expected to return in bigger games ahead of Flynn Perez.

u/Kind_Security_9931 + u/BigTonkaTroy on r/hawktalk (comments, scores 8+)
Community Questions

What people are asking about Jack Scrimshaw

Mentioned in
  • What changes should Hawthorn make for the R7 Suns game with Sicily and Moore suspended?
    J. SicilyDEFTop: Scrimshaw for Sicily, Dalton and Gunston in for Moore and McCabe (60%)
    24
  • Where should Joshua Weddle play — remain on the wing or move back to half-back and defence?
    J. WeddleDEFTop: Keep him on the wing — goalkicking will come (40%)
    19
  • What is Hawthorn's best 23 when fully healthy?
    UnknownTop: Chol and Day in; Dear and Maginness out (60%)
    12