Broad scraped 57 in Richmond's 37-point home humiliation by Adelaide at the MCG — 11 above his 46 BE, but this is a veteran premium DEF averaging 67.3 in a team getting systematically flogged. Cash gen is negative at -$2,370 per round. The R8 bounce-back (73) hasn't stuck; Richmond are just too broken a context for him to consistently hit his ceiling. Sell now and redeploy — you're losing ground every week you hold.