Broad posted 65 in Richmond's 114-point SCG humiliation by Sydney — the team managed only 56 AFL points and were utterly dismantled, yet Broad returned 65. That is a respectable individual effort in the worst possible team context. However, cash gen is negative at -$1,822 per round at $319.4k and a 59.5 average. Richmond's environment is simply too broken for a veteran premium DEF to consistently perform. The R9 sell verdict was right and remains right — exit now before further price erosion in a team that is haemorrhaging points every week.
Signals1/3 · Weak alignment
Form
Stable
Trajectory
-$2k/wk
Consistency
Variable
Nathan Broad
·⚠ test - Leg/Calf (Test)
DEF
SC Avg55.3
Form
Break-even46↑ rising
Price$312k3wk ↑ $350k
Owned—
Value0.2poor
UNDERVALUED — 9 pts above BE. Price rising.$-2k/wk
R0
—
R1
81
R2
49
R3
R4
45
R5
86
R6
71
R7
40
How they compare
Nathan Broad
DEF
Ryan Gardner
DEF
—
—
Form
R10
64
R11
72
R12
65
R14
64
R15
45
R16
82
R7
25
Pricing
Price$312k
Price$120k
Breakeven46
Breakeven18
Cash/wk+$-2k
Cash/wk+$0k
But this is generic. Your team changes everything.
Sam Mitchell
MID
AVG94
3GM102
BKE88
PRICE$485k
Trade Mitchell → upgrade Xerri to Grundy. Frees $38k and fixes your ruck.
Your personalised recommendation
Read the latest SuperCoach thought pieces and player intel — grounded in prices, form, and community signal — before you pull the trigger on Nathan Broad.