De Koning posted 75 away in Darwin as STK went down by 29 — technically above his 53 BE but utterly unremarkable for a ruck averaging 81 who has shed $35k since R5. Cash gen is -$6,683 per round and the ruck split with Marshall at St Kilda has capped his ceiling all season. The R8 "revenge game" bounce to 88 did not hold. Sell him now while there is still meaningful money to recover — the structural problems are not going away and the price will keep sliding.
Tom De Koning
Tom De Koning
RUCLachlan Mcandrew
RUCDecision
Should I trade Tom De Koning?
Form, breakeven, and a comparable replacement weighed up.
Recent intel
Tom De Koning had a strong R10 performance for St Kilda, described as having "thrown the monkey off his back" and visibly enjoying playing alongside Rowan Marshall. Community sentiment was that TDK is finally fulfilling his potential in a shared ruck role.
Tom De Koning returned to face Carlton (his former club). Community consensus is he should not be booed given the contract circumstances - STK reportedly offered significantly more money. Sympathetic sentiment toward TDK from Carlton fans.
Marshall's presence at the club limits De Koning's role and upside. Community concern that the two-ruck split reduces De Koning's fantasy scoring ceiling.
Community consensus is bearish on De Koning despite pre-season hype around new ruck rules favouring him. Multiple users recommend trading out, citing underperformance relative to expectations.
Tom De Koning mentioned alongside Zach Flanders as questionable performers after STK vs Port Adelaide post-match. Community not fully satisfied with his output in a narrow win.
One user upgraded T De Koning to Gawn as part of a ruck restructure, treating him as a stepping stone rather than a keeper.
Tom De Koning (TDK) sharing ruck duties with Marshall at St Kilda limits his individual SC ceiling despite being a good AFL ruck option.
What people are asking about Tom De Koning
- Will Jack Silvagni and Tom De Koning get booed by Carlton fans when they return to face their former club?67J. SilvagniDEFTop: Boo JSOS, not TDK (40%)
- Which players are the best upgrade and downgrade targets heading into Round 7?24UnknownTop: Anderson and Tsatas are the mid downgrade targets (45%)