McKay Was Scoring 73 in Round 1. The Registry Called Sell in Round 6. The 25% Still Holding Are Too Late.
The community split 65/25 on trading McKay after his Round 9 drop. The registry has been calling sell since Round 6. Here's the data trail that settles it.
McKay Was Scoring 73 in Round 1. The Registry Called Sell in Round 6. The 25% Still Holding Are Too Late.
The VFL circuit-breaker argument is sound. It just doesn't apply to the player Ben McKay has been since Round 6.
When Ben McKay was dropped for Round 9, the community split predictably: 65% said trade out, 25% said hold and watch the VFL reset do its work. The 25% aren't wrong about the mechanism — a VFL stint can reset confidence and earn a recall within a fortnight. They're wrong about where McKay's problem started.
The registry called sell in Round 6. Not Round 9. Round 6.
The Two Stances
Trade out (65%): McKay scored 23 in Round 8 in a 64-point loss to Brisbane, then got dropped for Round 9. His last three scores read 51, 42, 23. The community thread was unambiguous post-Round 7 — "scared with the ball," calls to drop him, visible decline in body-on-body contests. Price stalled at $238.6k with a 35 BE. The form case for holding is gone.
Hold for VFL recall (25%): McKay scored 87 in Round 5 — his season best — proving the ceiling exists. The drop is a confidence reset, not a death sentence. Essendon's backline lacks depth; he could be back within 1–2 rounds if he dominates in the VFL. Sell-low risk is real on a player who's shown he can score.
What the Registry Saw — and When It Saw It
The registry issued a sell verdict in Round 6. That's two rounds before the drop and one round before the community narrative fully turned. The signal was community intel flagging "scared with the ball" post-Round 7 (high confidence), combined with a price that had stalled despite a 37 BE that should have been generating cash.
Round 7's hold verdict was a context call. McKay scored 51 in Essendon's 77-point Anzac Day hammering by Collingwood — a score produced in a game that was over by halftime. That's noise, not signal.
Round 8 confirmed the thesis: 23 points, dropped for Round 9, $238.6k and bleeding.
The trajectory from Round 6 onward: 42, 51, 23. Average across those three rounds: 38.7. His 35 BE means he was barely generating cash across that stretch even when he played.
The R1 Version Isn't Coming Back This Season
The 25% holding McKay are waiting for the Round 1 player — 73 points, $250k, "smash-select lock," elite cash cow credentials. That player earned his buy verdict and the ownership he got.
The Round 8 player scored 23 in a blowout loss and got dropped. The Round 5 87-pointer that gave the hold camp hope is now looking like an outlier — one score in a run of 44, 38, 87, 42, 51, 23.
The VFL will tell you something in 1–2 rounds. But every week you hold costs you a spot in your team and real price decay at $238.6k. The registry said sell in Round 6 because the trend was already written. Round 9's drop was the confirmation.
The Call
Trade him out. The 25% are correct that McKay has a ceiling — he showed it in Round 5. The problem is the ceiling has a very specific prerequisite: a functioning Essendon backline structure that currently does not exist.
The data is settled. The registry was right in Round 6 and the community caught up in Round 9.
Updated: 24 May 2026. Data sourced from RookieBible intel registry.
Check the full McKay intel on his player page. Pre-briefed. Opinionated. The more you challenge it, the sharper it gets.
Thursday night rookie intel. Free.
Team announcements, late outs, and the definitive rookie reliability update every Thursday night before lockout.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Related articles
He Kicked Three Goals. Richmond Still Dropped Him for Round 11.
Liam Fawcett was dropped for Round 11 despite kicking three goals. At $132.4k, the cash gen window is closed. The registry says avoid — get out before the price adjusts.
Read article →Grundy's 203 Will Have Coaches Scrambling. The Registry Says Sit on Your Hands.
Grundy scored 203 in R10 against a ruck-less Collingwood. His real average is 132. Here is why buying at $685k after the spike is the wrong move and what the registry says to do.
Read article →Jones Scored 111 Away From Home. GWS Only Scored 71.
Darcy Jones scored 111 in an away loss in Round 10 — his third game back from ACL. Output is escalating 86→57→111 and the registry says buy. Here's the full read.
Read article →