Carroll Has Scored Three Centuries This Season. He's $303k.

At $303k averaging 105 against a 45 BE, Carroll is the best-value mid-pricer in the comp right now — and if you're not on him, you're subsidising everyone who is.

Carroll just posted 105 in St Kilda's 36-point home win over Richmond. Third ton of 2026. Season average: 105. Breakeven: 45. Cash gen: $7,344 per round. He costs $303,500.

Why Half the Competition Isn't On Jack Carroll SuperCoach 2026

He debuted at $119.9k and got labelled a cash cow. Classic acquisition arc: buy cheap, ride the price climb, trade out at peak. That's what a lot of coaches did.

The problem is Carroll didn't stop scoring after they traded him out. He kept pushing 76, 106, then 105 this week. The cash cow label stuck even after he'd crossed into premo scoring territory, and SC is notoriously slow at repricing that upward in your head.

That's the mispricing. The registry has been flagging it since R7 when he first hit the century mark. The R9 moment — 43 exact on his BE in a road loss to Gold Coast — was not a signal to panic. One flat score in an away game in a tight contest. R10 answered it with 105.

Jack Carroll SuperCoach Value R10 2026

Here is what the registry is working from:

• Role: Locked STK halfback. Has not shifted once all season. Job security is green every week.
• Scoring run since R5: 76, 32, 106, 57, 43, 105. Two centuries in that run, both genuine. Average: 105.
• Cash gen: $7,344/round at $303.5k. Value score 0.346 — elite for his price tier.
• BE: 45. He cleared it by 60 points in R10. Cleared it in nine of ten rounds this season.

The market hasn't caught up. He's producing premo output at mid-pricer price and that gap has not fully closed.

Should I Trade In Jack Carroll for Round 11?

Yes. The math is simple. You're getting 105-average scoring for $303.5k when the equivalent premo runs $550k-ish. The cash gen at this price is exceptional — $7,344/round is faster generation than almost any traditional mid-price pick at this stage of the season.

Hold if you own him. Buy if you don't. The window where the market undervalues him this much won't stay open much longer.

Updated: 21 May 2026. Data sourced from RookieBible intel registry.

Pre-briefed. Opinionated. The more you challenge it, the sharper it gets.